'Football Talk' is a place for football fans to come and share their views on issues ranging from managers and their managerial styles, transfer stories, tactics used in matches, line-ups, etc. Also get links to your favourite football sites. Everyone is welcome to share their views here but no filthy words, and i am sure we all know what i mean...Enjoy views from around the world and expand your football knowledge!
Tuesday, 5 July 2011
Nasri, Modric or Schneider?
Hi! A little debate with a couple of my buddies as to which of the following players would help utd the most; Nasri, Modric or Schneider?
3 comments:
I love football
said...
I would most definitely go for Modric for one reason, he knows the English game and would probably lie deeper in midfield than the other two giving Rooney more room to operate in a 4-5-1 formation. Schneider and Nasri however have the advantage of being more goal-productive. But the Mod does get a couple every season...but can united pay his price?
Most definitely Schneider. He has the big match experience and temperament; world cup final and champions lge final. He has vision, can score goals both from open-play and from dead-ball situations. Also bear in mind that Dutch players settle down into the premiership quickly, definite purchase and send Nani the other way!
Interesting choice, Modric and Nasri are both premiership proven whilst Schneider has proven himself in the Netherlands, Spain and Italy as well as internationally. Comparing the stats on goals, assists and passes completed Nasri just edges Schneider, Modric is let by his goals record too few for the chances he creates. Apart from the odd foot wart they all stay fairly injury free. If it were possible to pick up two of the three I'd like to see Schneider and Nasri if only one then Nasri. Why? because he is younger, cheaper and I believe has an extra bit of flair. Chance are we won't get any of them...
3 comments:
I would most definitely go for Modric for one reason, he knows the English game and would probably lie deeper in midfield than the other two giving Rooney more room to operate in a 4-5-1 formation. Schneider and Nasri however have the advantage of being more goal-productive. But the Mod does get a couple every season...but can united pay his price?
Most definitely Schneider. He has the big match experience and temperament; world cup final and champions lge final. He has vision, can score goals both from open-play and from dead-ball situations. Also bear in mind that Dutch players settle down into the premiership quickly, definite purchase and send Nani the other way!
Interesting choice, Modric and Nasri are both premiership proven whilst Schneider has proven himself in the Netherlands, Spain and Italy as well as internationally. Comparing the stats on goals, assists and passes completed Nasri just edges Schneider, Modric is let by his goals record too few for the chances he creates. Apart from the odd foot wart they all stay fairly injury free. If it were possible to pick up two of the three I'd like to see Schneider and Nasri if only one then Nasri. Why? because he is younger, cheaper and I believe has an extra bit of flair. Chance are we won't get any of them...
Post a Comment